Navigating the Coronavirus crisis: Thoughts from five Perth industry leaders
What lessons for our industry can be learned from this unprecedented situation that the world is in? Bonfire Head of Marketing, Rene LeMerle, asked five local agency leaders for their thoughts.
The impact of COVID-19 Coronavirus is ever present. We’re all grappling with its effects on health, workplaces, society and our businesses. Its rapid onset has forced many of us on to the back foot. Strategic priorities have shifted. Forecasts are being downgraded. Bullish outlooks are being replaced with caution and conservatism.
Everyone’s looking for ways to protect the health and safety of staff, clients and families, whilst also ensuring the sustainability of business over the next 6 – 12 months. We reached out to some Perth’s leading agency heads, to see how they’re tackling the coronavirus situation, and for some strategy and marketing recommendations during such a crisis. Here’s what they had to say.
Gavin Bain – CEO, Meerkats
This may come as a surprise to some of you, but the advertising industry can occasionally have a rather inflated sense of its own importance in people’s lives. After all, as the people were furiously tearing loo paper from the shelves last week, it’s very unlikely that any of them were stopping to admire the perfect kerning of the logo or the fantastic innovations in 6-ply technology promised in the body copy.
But at the same time, brands can often underestimate the role they play in the day-to-day interactions people have online and in person. A strong brand voice and a compelling true purpose can deliver exponential value to a business in times of cultural and community upheaval – particularly when they are linked to a pragmatic benefit to the customer.
To return to toilet paper, it’s no surprise that ‘Who Gives A Crap’ benefitted immensely from the panic due to: a) a clear, practical and compelling business proposition, b) a fun and reassuring brand tone (with a strong social conscience baked in), and c) a constant presence on social media (owned), word of mouth referrals (earned) and direct digital marketing (paid).
This is the value of creating robust businesses and brands that are built on a bedrock of purpose, combined with charming and accessible creative that adds something to people’s lives. It’s often said that a great brand is forged in the fires of market depression, downturns and chaos – not business as usual.
Now is exactly the right time to clarify what exactly makes your brand something special, something to celebrate, and something to earn the front-of-mind awareness of a community largely trapped in their homes staring at screens. In many ways it’s a marketers’ paradise – a worldwide captive audience who are largely preoccupied with the same topic, all ready to hear something positive and inspiring from the brands they love.
So give it to them. This is the best time in recent history to show society exactly what you have to say in your business.
And if you need some quick advice to help you out with this, we’re always happy to help.
Clay Cook – CEO, Bonfire
These are unprecedented times. A multigenerational “once in a lifetime” crisis. And it’s understandably left many people and businesses in a panic.
We, like most businesses, have put the health and welfare our staff, and the greater Bonfire community, at the forefront of our activities. We need to work together to stem the spread of the virus. We rapidly rolled out our relevant risk management program and deployed remote work and client management procedures. It has ensured we’ve been able to keep “business as close to usual” for our clients, while protecting everyone. We have a way to go before things get better.
And the economic impact of coronavirus will linger on for years to come. So we’re working with our clients and partners to help insure their sustainable through these times.
As people shift to remote working arrangements, and quarantine/self-isolation becomes more prevalent, online will be even more critical for businesses. It’s really important that they maintain a strong digital presence.
But it’s far from “Marketing as usual”. Brands need to be sensitive to the times with their messaging and approach. People don’t want to be “sold” to at the moment. But people do still need products and services.
The businesses that will survive, are adapting and innovating. Trimming “fat”, not “muscle”.
Callum Mackenzie – Managing Director, Rare
As with most businesses, our priority in these unusual times is the health and welfare of our staff and their families, our clients and suppliers, and the continuation of normal services; but additionally as a business and as an industry we must adopt a pragmatic, calm and we believe optimistic view of the future.
In doing so at Rare, it positions us with the right mindset to work with our clients to providing support, advice and direction today and in the future.
Government and economic reports suggest that the worst months of infection are expected to be June, easing by September and all done be December. This will likely create an economic recession in the first quarter of FY21 (July to September – a 1 in 100 year economic event) but the Australian Government is well placed to manage it much better than any disaster or economic fallout in the past.
So even though we’re not at the bottom quite yet, we are optimistic that the worst effects of the Covid-19 crisis will be over relatively soon and we will be able to go back to our lives with some kind of normality.
Human beings are incredibly resilient – we have faced many crises before and come out stronger – and this one is no different, particularly at a time when our level of development and medical knowledge is the highest it has ever been in human history.
With that backdrop, our industry must accept the challenge thrown at it and adapt to the changing environment. Our staff will have individual concerns and situations that we will support and our clients will be presented with different challenges and real opportunities. We must join forces with them to hunt for the right resolution and direction and help deliver personal, social and business results that inspire confidence.
Deepening trust and engaging brands with their audiences and positively impacting behaviour. Having personally lived and worked through the Gulf War in Saudi Arabia, I have seen the impact that smart communications and advertising can achieve in troubled times – it will pay dividends through the recovery period and even strengthen the position of brands in the aftermath.
So let’s all wash our hands, stay positive, be good humans and focus on the brighter months ahead.
Rare is well and truly open for business and ready to work our wonder for anyone looking for an injection of positivity.
Paul Coghlan – Chief Creative Officer, Marketforce
What an interesting time we’re living and operating in. Our advice to our client partners, as well as businesses and brands more broadly, is centred around six particular areas.
Calm: People need a calm, steady hand during chaotic times. Brands should provide reassurance but be honest about how the crisis is affecting them.
Clarity: Provide clarity around expectations and what the organisation is doing to mitigate the effects of the crisis.
Certainty: Give them as much certainty as you can. Keep up with the government guidelines. Stick to the facts. Tell them what you are doing to fix problems.
Communication: Talk to your audience 1:1 as much as possible, talk in the first-person using company spokespeople. Support direct channels like EDM, Video & Social with TV, digital and print.
Community: Demonstrate what you are doing for the community, especially those at increased risk during the crisis.
Consistency: Don’t stop, continual communication is critical. Provide regular updates. The situation will change rapidly so you need to be ready to adapt and respond.
Mark Treasure – State Sales Director, oOh!media
While Covid-19 and the resulting economic concerns have seen some brands relook at their marketing approach, they still should be focusing on building and maintaining their presence as long as it is sensitive and aware of how consumers are affected.
Coca-Cola is a great example of how you can build brand while recognising the social and economic attitudes. In the great depression, by maintaining a presence and reflecting community sentiment, they were able to double sales and retain market share when the economy rebounded.
At oOh! one of our approaches during this time is to work with our customers to reflect their brand in customer-led community service messaging across our Out of Home medium.
15 Comments
So customers fighting over toilet paper don’t care about the kerning of your logo…but they do care about a) a clear, practical and compelling business proposition, b) a fun and reassuring brand tone (with a strong social conscience baked in), and c) a constant presence on social media (owned), word of mouth referrals (earned) and direct digital marketing (paid)? Hmmmmmm…
Interesting article CB however what happened to the female’s perspective? Did Perth close all the schools and they are therefore at home looking after their husband’s kids ? Come on … you know a large portion of the industry are women …and from what I remember very smart ones at that !
That’s a very valid point, and it was remiss of me not to have a greater diversity of perspective in the piece. While not an excuse, time and conflicting priorities, lead to the glaring oversight, that many of my very talented female peers have pointed out. And just an FYI, as a 50% solo dad, i’d probably be staying home looking after my boy if the schools closed anyway.
Here we go again!!! One good thing that will come out of this terrible situation, will be you youngsters realising how bloody good you had it, what a great country we had and how petty your identity politics have been. It’s time for you ‘woke’ to wake up and remove yourselves from in front of the mirror.
Over the next few months, I hope you start categorising yourselves as Australians and with it, demonstrate Australian spirit. God knows, we’ll need it. Your identity politics are destructive, divisive and will get us bloody nowhere.
Now take a bloody tissue and get back in line, like the rest of us.
All men?
That’s a fair call Jess (and Lessons whoever you are. Put your name, it won’t kill you) To be honest, mine was written substantively by Rikki Burns and Josh Edge so my mug shouldn’t be there at all! Perhaps we can get some additional thoughts from Nita, Jo, Mel W, Dixie, Ang Nutton. I reckon all ideas are welcome in these times.
And very well written by Rikki (and Josh et al.)
MARTIN TREVASKIS can I ask why you didn’t ask for any women’s comments here? Nothing against any of these fellers and their informed opinions but it seems a bit dated to only ask men what they think. When articles like this are run, (especially with headshots) it kinda becomes a bit self perpetuating too. If you’re prepared to take these developing comments on board you could re-run the article inclusive of a female perspective from within the industry and put a female face up there as well.
Keep safe and healthy and sane everyone.
Hello Renee,
Delightful to hear from you and thank you for your interest.
In fact, I didn’t ask anyone for their comments. This article was initiated and written by Rene LeMerle, Head of Marketing at Bonfire.
He contacted me and asked if I’d be interested in a piece on the topic. I am currently up to my neck trying to put together the Campaign Brief WA Awards in some form, so I appreciated his making the effort, which I know was done with the best of intentions.
However, if you have a perspective on the current situation you’d like to share, please send it to me and I will happily publish it.
Thanks also, to Really? (2020/03/19 at 10:06 pm) and MILF (2020/03/19 at 10:19 pm) – who may or may not be the same person – for your interest. I’d be happy to publish your very forthright counter points-of-view if you would be happy to put your real name/s to your comments.
You have the advantage of knowing who these people are and where they are from. It’s only fair that they should have the same clarity about your identities.
And to Good Read, thanks for your note of support. I had actually planned a more extensive series but a combination of circumstances meant I had to change the approach at short notice and only cover those four particular leading women. Nevertheless, I still enjoyed doing it very much and I’m glad you enjoyed reading it.
All the best,
Martin Trevaskis
I agree with Renee and Jess.
Firstly I’d like to say thank you Martin for your swift response and clarification.
I’m sure neither Rene nor yourself had any malice in choosing only white male respondents and publishing the article respectively, but it is disappointing to see diversity continue to be overlooked in this conversation and our industry more widely. Perth industry leaders Nita and Jo from Trilogy, for example, would have been great to hear from on this topic.
Yeah, this obviously isn’t talking about people in the moment of panic buying – rather the broader implications of how a brand should position themselves before and during a response to a brand crisis (or, in this case, a societal crisis)….
A) Who Gives A Crap is toilet paper and tissues available to order online. It’s cheap and convenient and allows you to avoid the chaos of the supermarkets. Practical and clear.
B) They are 100% recycled toilet paper which give 50% of their profits to WaterAid to build toilets and improve sanitation in the developing world. Just as importantly, they’re funny and charming while they’re at it (“You’ve got a nice bum!” “Wipe away your worries!” is printed in giant lettering on every box). This is win/win for panic buyers who want to feel good about themselves and the world while they panic (a vastly under-utilised sales metric).
C) They were EVERYWHERE in paid, owned and earned during the initial panic period, with the first thing people-in-the-know were saying being, “You should try WGAC”, “I already got my order from WGAC”, their social presence ratcheting up and some smart responses (even when they were “completely wiped out”) to some difficult business decisions.
Nothing’s ever perfect, and a lot of the above stuff is somewhat subliminal (which makes it even more powerful) but I would always take the above strategy/brand equity/clever creative over the alternative during a market downturn!
Hi everyone.
It’s appropriate for me to weigh into this discussion.
First and foremost, Martin didn’t write the article, and Campaign Brief didn’t ask me to conrtibute it.
It was an undertaking I made with the best of intentions, to spread some positive thinking and forward vision in what are tough times for everyone.
I appreciate everyone’s comments, and acknowledge that it was a glaring oversight not having a greater diversity of perspective in the article. I wont bore you with excuses. As rightly stated above, there is a plenthora of extremely talented women in this industry that have insights that we all want to read.
Given I am an Indian looking, Aussie sounding, faux French guy, with what many mistake for a women’s name, I almost epitomise diversity. But not to make light of the situation, I meant no malice by the selection of contributors.
And without it feeling like, “too little, too late”, and assuming my talented female peers are happy to contribute, I’ll create a follow up article next week, to provide a broader view of ideas, suggestions and recommendations during this challenging times.
So be safe, stay positive and keep your distance.
D’oh
Well, much like COVID-19, this escalated quickly…
Wait, Rene’s a dude?!